Looking Back at Fleetwood's
Entry and Exit From the
European RV Market
As Fleetwood did its strategic planning in the late
1980's and early 1990's, the company looked at its potential for
growth beyond North America and it became obvious that the next
largest RV market in the world was in Europe.
Fleetwood had served the European market on a limited
scale over the last 20 years on an export basis and felt it knew
the market as well as any company could being on the outside.
Elden Smith, vice president, RV Group, said, "We
really didn't know that market from the inside. We also had determined
after going through several currency fluctuations, if you're working
outside of the market you are very vulnerable to these changes."
Fleetwood decided to explore having a manufacturing
presence in Europe. For the next two years, Fleetwood studied
the market, then met with the major manufacturers in Europe, talked
to them about its intentions to ultimately come to Europe as a
manufacturer, and the possibility of making an acquisition to
get started.
After that research, Fleetwood believed that Germany
would have the strongest, fastest growing market and also had
the strongest economy in Europe. Another factor was the fact that
the motorhome market particularly had been strong in Germany.
Smith said, "We had a previous relationship with a company,
Niesmann+Bischoff, in Germany through export. They had imported
some of our products throughout the 1970's. After the exchange
rates changed, the company was no longer able to import competitively,
so it began manufacturing a motorhome of its own. During the 1980's
Niesmann+Bischoff built an excellent reputation for itself and
its product, a high-end motorhome.
"When we talked to them about an acquisition,
they were interested and it looked like a way for us to get into
the motorhome market in Europe with a high quality company with
a strong reputation. We could help them develop lower priced products,
more competitively priced, higher value products which would get
us into the mainstream of the market. To make a long story short
that's essentially what we did, we bought 80% of the company."
Within a few months after the acquisition, the German
economy began to soften, eventually leading to the deepest economic
recession experienced by Germany since the end of World War II.
In addition, the German government, as part of the German reunification,
had to make a significant investment to bring East Germany's economy
up to West Germany's. That is when a 15-percent surtax was imposed
on all income, both corporate and personal.
"Obviously the combined effect of economic recession
and the income tax surcharge had a real dampening effect on the
economy," Smith continued. "The discretionary income
of the German people became limited. That's when we started to
see the decline of the European motorhome market. We developed
two new product lines, moved the company into middle and lower
priced products and moved up from the 16th largest to the 6th
largest manufacturer in Germany. The industry at the same time
went from 23,000 units per year down to about 13,000. When we
looked at our situation we decided we didn't have the breadth
of products nor the depth of dealer organizations that we needed
to grow."
Fleetwood reviewed its commitment in Europe annually.
The company was losing between $4-6 million a year which was a
burden on the United States operations. Smith said, "As we
looked forward for the next several years, the prospects for improvement
in the German economy were not good. In fact, they're basically
projecting at least two more years of recession and probably more.
It just became more and more evident that there was no real way
we could regain that investment without making another tremendous
investment."
Fleetwood started putting out feelers to other companies
that might want to pick up these product lines and recently sold
its interest in the European company to one of the largest RV
companies in Europe.
Does that mean that Fleetwood is out of the European
market for good. Not necessarily, according to Smith. He said,
"Looking at it long term, I don't think there is any indication
that we would never be interested in going into either Germany
or Europe again. We will continue to evaluate the market potential
from a strategic standpoint. We are still convinced that the best
way to compete in Europe is to manufacture in the European community
and not try to export to it.
"Somewhere down the road, it's entirely possible
that we would choose to go back."
RVN
|